- 1928 Leon Delaplaine* (*) Deceased
- 1929-1930 Springer Tam*
- 1931 W. "Billy" Patterson*
- 1932-1937 T.C. Schley*
- 1938, 1939, 1948 Joe Meyers*
- 1940 Walter Laubenthal*
- 1941 Tom Trawick*
- 1942-45, 1949-50 Capt. E.I. Newberry*
- 2002 Posthumously Awarded to Jake Delaplaine*
- 1946 Howard Mathis*
- 1947 Foster Pfleger*
- 1951-52 Perry Cox*
- 1953-54, 1956-57 Joe Hall*
- 1955 T.P. McArdle*
- 1958 B.F. Mangold*
- 1959-60, 1963 Roy L. Sellers*
- 1961-62 Leo Ginn*
- 1964-65 Sanford Jernigan
- 1966-77 Frank Kleinschrodt*
- 1968-69 Steve Harrington*
- 1970 Don Dunnam, Sr.*
- 1971 Jim Ritchie
- 1972 Willie Gibson
- 1973, 1987 Henry Mouchett*
- 1974 John Fay*
- 1975 Norman Foster, Sr.*
- 1976-77 Bennie Hayes*
- 1978 Bob Harper*
- 1979 Doc Harrington
- 1980 Norbert Long
- 1981 Bing Bingham*
- 1982 Maury Hazen
- 1983 Benny Anderson
- 1984 Bob Passett*
- 1985 Tom Batty
- 1986 Jim Edwards
- 1987 Toby Gurley
- 1988 Jim McNeil
- 1989 Jim Foster
- 1990 Ken Kleinschrodt
- 1991-92 Norman Thames
- 1993 W.C. Smith*
- 1994 Nick Blakeney
- 1995 Joel Hoffman
- 1996-97 Pete O'Neal
- 1998 R.O. Douglas (Honorary)
- 1998 Mike Hammer
- 1999 Duane Jones
- 2000-01 Paul Quinn
- 2002 Jeff Davis
- 2003 Jack Andrade
- 2004-05 Johnny Wacker
- 2006 Blan Page
- 2007- Harvie Jordan
| | GYA Commodores from Buccaneer Yacht Club | 1950 Fred Clarke* 1966 Foster Pfleger* 1981 Roy Sellers 2001 Ken Kleinschrodt - 2007 Tom Batty
|
|